• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Makeup and Beauty Blog | Makeup Reviews, Swatches and How-To MakeupMakeup and Beauty Blog | Makeup Reviews, Swatches and How-To Makeup

A beauty blog blooming with fresh makeup reviews, swatches and beauty tips from your friendly neighborhood beauty addict

  • Home
  • About
    • About
    • Contact
    • FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
    • Advertising & Media
  • Categories
    • Product Reviews
    • Makeup
    • Skincare & Fragrance
    • Style & Fashion
    • Hair
    • Nails
    • Tips & Tutorials
    • Just for Fun
  • Brands
  • Store

This or That: Lipstick Edition

September 3rd, 2020 by Karen 23 Comments

mac lipsticks national lipstick day
Smooch!

Anybody else out there really miss wearing lipstick when they’re out and about? I’ve been thinking about it a lot lately, with fall — which usually means the return of dark, vampy lips — just around the corner. Sometimes I still wear lipstick ? around the house…and sometime I’ll rock a thin layer of liquid matte lipstick underneath my mask (which seems to transfer the least).

Anywho, it’s time for another round of This or That!

How to play

Pick one or the other for each of the questions below, and copy/paste your answers in the comments. Can’t wait to see your picks! Mine are listed below. ?

Copy and paste

  • Matte or cream finish?
  • Coral or rose?
  • Sheer or pigmented?
  • Blended or unblended lip liner?
  • Overdrawn or not?
  • Orangey reds or bluish reds?
  • Brown or pastel?
  • Lip brush or straight from the tube?

Matte or cream finish?

I love both, but I’ll go with matte because I like how it photographs.

Coral or rose?

Coral, 100%.

Sheer or pigmented?

Pigmented, please. I like the flexibility.

Blended or unblended lip liner?

Unblended. I know, I know…but I’ve been feeling ’90s makeup lately, and I think the unblended lip looks cool.

Overdrawn or not?

Not, although I have done the whole overdrawn lip liner thing before; it’s just one of those phases you need to work through, LOL!

Orangey reds or bluish reds?

YARGH. This is hard. I guess orangey reds!

Brown or pastel shades?

Brown.

Lip brush or straight from the tube?

Straight from the tube, baby.

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,

Karen ?

This or That: Lipstick Edition / Originally published September 3rd, 2020

There are 23 comments on this post. Leave yours.

Categories: Just For Fun, Makeup

Previous Post: FOTD: A Clean Makeup Look With Chocolate Wings and Matte Peach and Pink Tones
Next Post: FOTD: Matte Monochromatic Makeup in Rusty Brown Tones (And With One Eyeshadow!)

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Eileen says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 10:22 am

    Matte or cream finish? Cream for sure. I’ve never seen a matte lip (except for all those photoshopped pictures in ads and on Instagram) that didn’t look dry and wrinkled–even on young women. Unless our lips are packed with filler, we all have lip lines to one degree or another and matte exacerbates the look of them. End of mini-rant! LOL

    Coral or rose? My natural lip color is a medium mauve-leaning rose so I’m all about MLBB shades or shades a bit darker that are rose.

    Sheer or pigmented? I prefer sheer. They’re more forgiving on my old, dry lips.

    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended. I remember “ring around the lips” from the 60’s and 90’s so been there, seen that, done that.

    Overdrawn or not? Not.

    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Bluish reds.

    Brown or pastel? I don’t really like either one but, since all my lipsticks are on the sheer side, I’ll say pastel because my natural lip color will show through and darken the shade a bit. Being an older woman, shades that are too pale wash me out.

    Lip brush or straight from the tube? It depends on the color and pigmentation. The deeper or more opaque the lipstick, the more likely I am to use a brush.

    Reply
  2. Rachel says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 11:04 am

    Matte or cream finish?
    Cream.
    Coral or rose?
    Coral.
    Sheer or pigmented?
    Pigmented.
    Blended or unblended lip liner?
    Blended.
    Overdrawn or not?
    Not.
    Orangey reds or bluish reds?
    Orangey in summer, bluish in winter.
    Brown or pastel?
    Brown.
    Lip brush or straight from the tube?
    Tube.
    I’m sad about lipstick! I have so many and I hope to be able to use them one day again! I thought about ordering MAC Diva, a deep vampy red that I got a sample of, but then I thought, what’s the point?! I don’t go anywhere and when I do I am wearing a darn mask!

    Reply
  3. Suzanne C says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 11:26 am

    Matte or cream finish? = Cream.
    Coral or rose? = Rose.
    Sheer or pigmented? = Pigmented.
    Blended or unblended lip liner? = Blended.
    Overdrawn or not? = Not.
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? = Bluish reds. (I can’t do anything orangey.)
    Brown or pastel? = Brown.
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? = Straight from the tube, but smoothed out with a lip brush.

    Yes, I love lipstick and I miss wearing it out so much! I comfort myself by wearing tinted lip balm at home, though. The new-ish one from Shiseido is pretty good and of course I’m going to have to try the one from Selena Gomez that dropped today.

    Reply
  4. Chelsea says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 11:37 am

    Matte or cream finish?

    Matte!

    Coral or rose?

    Coral!

    Sheer or pigmented?

    Sheer for real life (not performing). I like the freckle on my lip to show.

    Blended or unblended lip liner?

    Blended!

    Overdrawn or not?

    Not!

    Orangey reds or bluish reds?

    Orangey reds!

    Brown or pastel?

    I can’t pull off either!

    Lip brush or straight from the tube?

    Straight from the tube.

    Reply
  5. Christine says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 11:59 am

    Matte or cream finish?
    Cream.

    Coral or rose?
    Rose, very very light rose.

    Sheer or pigmented?
    Sheer, like panty hose for my lips.

    Blended or unblended lip liner?
    Blended.

    Overdrawn or not?
    Not; happy with my shape. Though sometimes I will not dip the cupid’s bow and will go straight across.

    Orangey reds or bluish reds?
    Bluish reds FER SHER. Any orangey makes my teeth color look nasty.

    Brown or pastel?
    Sheer AF pastel.

    Lip brush or straight from the tube?
    Straight from the tube!

    I look forward to Zoom sessions now because it’s the only time I’ll get to wear lipstick! I have all this pandemic Lip Glass that I no longer want, however, and it’s not bringing me joy. I hate to throw it away. Maybe I could just gloss my lids!

    Reply
    • Karen says

      September 3rd, 2020 at 2:04 pm

      I think you might be able to Back to MAC your Lipglass!

      Reply
  6. Tatiana says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 12:28 pm

    Matte or cream finish? Cream. My lips need all the moisture they can get.
    Coral or rose? Rose
    Sheer or pigmented? Either
    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended. At least when I actually bother to do liner.
    Overdrawn or not? Not.
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Bluish.
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Straight from the tube. I’ll use a clean, firm brush after, only if I need to clean up the edge.
    I miss wearing lipstick out of the house. Sometimes lipstick was the only makeup I wore. I’m going through my lipsticks and wearing a different color every day, until I wear them all. Some are old and are getting tossed. Some of the “meh” colors and/or formulations are getting tossed too. I mean, how many red lipsticks do I really need? Trying to find the best of each color and sticking with those.

    Reply
    • Karen says

      September 3rd, 2020 at 2:06 pm

      I think one needs ALL THE REDS. lol Or maybe that’s just the hoarder in me?

      Reply
  7. ericca says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 12:36 pm

    Matte or cream finish?
    both , i love both , depends on the mood
    Coral or rose?
    neither
    Sheer or pigmented?
    depends on the mood
    Blended or unblended lip liner?
    blended
    Overdrawn or not?
    i have great lips , no overdrawing
    Orangey reds or bluish reds?
    bluish red
    Brown or pastel?
    depends on the mood
    Lip brush or straight from the tube?
    straight from the tube

    Reply
  8. Rachel Runyan says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 1:28 pm

    Matte or cream finish? Cream is my favorite lipstick finish.

    Coral or rose? Coral (I usually go with bright red- or orange- based corals.)

    Sheer or pigmented? Pigmented. I could always sheer it out.

    Blended or unblended lip liner? Unblended, but matching.

    Overdrawn or not? Slightly overdrawn, yes. My lips are losing volume due to age.

    Orangey reds or bluish reds? I love neutral reds the best, but I suppose I’ll go with orangey reds because I wear warmer cheek and eye colors more than cooler ones.

    Brown or pastel? Brown, hands down! I’m not a huge fan of pastel anything.

    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Straight from the tube. I don’t have the time, need, or inclination to use a brush on the daily.

    Reply
  9. Efrain says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 2:11 pm

    I miss wearing lipstick, but at least the pandemic helped me understand why using mascara is a game-changer. Here my answers:

    Matte or cream finish?
    Matte but hydrating please.

    Coral or rose?
    Rose, orange isn’t my friend.

    Sheer or pigmented?
    Pigmented, like you said, I also like versatility.

    Blended or unblended lip liner?
    Blended, I still don’t like the look of unblended lip liner.

    Overdrawn or not?
    I think it’s one of those things that can go really wrong, really fast, so no.

    Orangey reds or bluish reds?
    Bluish red, they make me look more glamorous.

    Brown or pastel?
    Brown, but please with enough pink so I don’t look dead.

    Lip brush or straight from the tube?
    Straight from the tube, who has time to use a lip brush?

    Reply
  10. Amy says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 2:21 pm

    Fun poll! I totally miss being able to wear lipstick daily.

    Matte or cream finish?
    Cream. Matte just doesn’t work and veers into lined and creased territory too easily on me.

    Coral or rose?
    Coral. My whole face is pink-toned, so rosey lipstick tends to look like a neutral on me but is not all that flattering. It blends in for a monochromatic look, but rarely in a good way!

    Sheer or pigmented?
    Both! More sheer these days. Bur I love a bold pigment. And I love to build and layer various colors to get a multi-faceted, rich pigment.

    Blended or unblended lip liner?
    Blended, for sure. Sometimes I lean slightly unblended or chromatic, but not often. It’s a very particular look I rarely have occasion to prefer.

    Overdrawn or not?
    Very, very rarely. It’s hard for me to control the outcome, I’ve already got pretty full lips, and I feel it looks kind of sloppy and artificial on me. I’m sure others make use of this technique beautifully!

    Orangey reds or bluish reds?
    Bluish reds, for sure!!! No contest. Orange looks awful with my skin tone!

    Brown or pastel?
    Pastel pink. Or brick-red brown.

    Lip brush or straight from the tube?
    Tube. Though I like the concept of a brush, I rarely have the patience! And I tend to reapply every few hours, which means I’d have to tote around a lip brush and clean it between uses….too much hassle for not enough payoff!

    Reply
  11. Jan says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 3:34 pm

    I definitely miss lipstick. I have a lifetime supply, but often treated myself to a new lippie. Even if I didn’t have much other makeup on, I always put lipstick on before going into a store or somewhere. Now I only put some on before a Zoom meeting, but it’s not the same. Seems like forever since I bought a new lippie and I miss it.

    Reply
  12. Jennifer Emmett says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 5:14 pm

    How fun!!

    Matte or cream finish? I’m going to pick a matte, a nude one.
    Coral or rose? Pale rose.
    Sheer or pigmented? Sheer!
    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended.
    Overdrawn or not? Overdrawn, nobody can tell b/c I blend. Right??
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Dark, creepy, blue red. From Necromancy!!
    Brown or pastel? Brown sounds nice.
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Toob.

    Reply
  13. Savannah says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 5:21 pm

    I’ll participate just for fun- with the answers I’d have chosen a few years back. I can no longer just pick up any lipstick anymore (some strange allergy to beeswax which seems to be in every lip formula ever). I’m still bitter about it. My lips were my best facial feature and I lost my ability to glam them up. But nowadays with masks… everyone’s in the same boat as me.
    Coral or rose? Rose
    Sheer or pigmented? Depending
    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended
    Overdrawn or not? Not
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Bluish reds
    Brown or pastel? Brown
    Lip brush or straight from the tube?
    Usually the tube

    Reply
  14. Nikki Wogoman says

    September 3rd, 2020 at 8:24 pm

    Matte or cream finish? Matte, as long as it’s not one of those weird mattes that always look too dry.
    Coral or rose? I’m cool-toned, so I’ll have to go with rose. The only corals I look good in are the really pinky ones, like Urban Decay 100 Degrees.
    Sheer or pigmented? Pigmented. I do technically own a sheer lipstick-Urban Decay 100 Degrees, actually!-but it (luckily!) goes on more semisheer than sheer.
    Blended or unblended lip liner? I don’t actually wear lip liner, but blended looks better than not. Unblended can work if the liner and lipstick are in the same color family, though.
    Overdrawn or not? Not.
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Both!
    Brown or pastel? I’ll have to go with pastel-the cool undertones strike again!
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Straight from the tube.

    Reply
  15. Jade says

    September 4th, 2020 at 5:08 am

    I’ve started wearing bright red lipstick around the house and to walk the dog, I miss it so much. Will probably switch to darker colors in the fall. I love another lady’s idea to wear a different lipstick every day. I may try that! Love lipstick!!

    Matte or cream finish?
    Love a matte lipstick!

    Coral or rose?
    Coral

    Sheer or pigmented?
    Pigmented because you can always blot it down

    Blended or unblended lip liner?
    Blended

    Overdrawn or not?
    My lips are already so full, I struggle with where exactly to put the lip liner to start without looking like a clown

    Orangey reds or bluish reds?
    Orangey reds!

    Brown or pastel?
    Brown

    Lip brush or straight from the tube?
    Tube although I’ve been enjoying copying KJH and using an eyeshadow brush sometimes.

    Reply
  16. Kim says

    September 4th, 2020 at 7:04 am

    Happy Friday, my friend! I hope you have a nice weekend and that the fire/air quality situation have improved. I’ve actually worn a bit of Almost Lipstick Black Honey twice in the last week. That’s a lot for me, even pre-mask. 🙂

    Matte or cream finish? Cream. I find mattes to be more drying.
    Coral or rose? Maybe brownish rose? HAHA!
    Sheer or pigmented? Sheer.
    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended.
    Overdrawn or not? I have a small mouth so I should overdraw. And I probably do. By accident!
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Bluish reds.
    Brown or pastel? Brown.
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Straight from the tube!

    Reply
  17. Adele says

    September 4th, 2020 at 10:31 am

    Matte or cream finish? Cream. Matte is too drying and flat looking for my taste
    Coral or rose? Coral if it’s a peachy one. Rose if it’s a warm one.
    Sheer or pigmented? Both/either! Love sheer dark colors, and pigmented medium colors.
    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended. The less obvious the better
    Overdrawn or not? Not…see above 🙂
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Love the bluish reds on other people but I can’t carry them off due to my skin tone.
    Brown or pastel? Brown, I guess? If it jas some red or pink in it.
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Straight from the tube.

    Reply
  18. Christina says

    September 4th, 2020 at 12:18 pm

    Copy and paste

    Matte or cream finish? Matte
    Coral or rose? Rose but I love coral
    Sheer or pigmented? Pigmented
    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended
    Overdrawn or not? Yes overdrawn or I wouldn’t have a lips : (
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Bluish? I still can’t figure out the difference? I’m color-challenged
    Brown or pastel? Pastel
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Tube the quicker the better.

    Reply
  19. Marcia says

    September 4th, 2020 at 1:59 pm

    Matte or creme finish? I prefer creme finish.
    Coral or rose? I like both colors.
    Sheer or pigmented? Pigmented.
    Blended or unblended lip liner? I almost never wear lip liner.
    Overdrawn or not? On the rare times I wore lip liner, I don’t overdraw.
    Orangey reds or bluish reds? Bluish reds.
    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Straight from the tube.

    Reply
    • Marcia says

      September 4th, 2020 at 5:23 pm

      Oops I forgot, brown or pastel? I like both.

      Reply
  20. Kecia says

    September 4th, 2020 at 8:02 pm

    I’m a lip product junkie, so I miss wearing lipstick outside. I don’t go out much, so I rock different lip looks around the house.

    Matte or cream finish? Matte lipsticks generally last longer, but my dry lips prefer the moisture of a cream.

    Coral or rose? Coral, but it has to be the right shade.

    Sheer or pigmented? Pigmented. You can sheer out a pigmented lip color, but you can’t build up a sheer one.

    Blended or unblended lip liner? Blended, but not necessarily matching.

    Overdrawn or not? Never overdrawn.

    Orangey reds or bluish reds? I wear both, but bluish reds are my favorite.

    Brown or pastel? Neither

    Lip brush or straight from the tube? Straight from the tube most of the time.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Welcome to Makeup and Beauty Blog

Welcome to Makeup and Beauty Blog! My name is Karen, and I’m a freelance writer obsessed with makeup.

Makeup and Beauty Blog features daily product reviews, makeup tips and beauty news — like an interactive version of a monthly print magazine, except with occasional pictures of my cat.

Recent Posts

Sundays With Tabs the Cat, Makeup and Beauty Blog Mascot, Vol. 878

Makeup and Beauty Blog Monday Poll, Vol. 894

Makeup and Beauty Blog Monday Poll, Vol. 893

Makeup and Beauty Blog Monday Poll, Vol. 892

Makeup and Beauty Blog Monday Poll, Vol. 891

/* real people should not fill this in and expect good things – do not remove this or risk form bot signups */

Social

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Featured Posts

Sundays With Tabs the Cat, Makeup and Beauty Blog Mascot, Vol. 771

Lady Unicorn

Weird Things I Like to Do

brows fill out beforehand

Before You Pluck or Wax Your Brows, You Must Do This

current bare skin status

What’s One Thing That Drastically Changed Your Skin for the Better?

Copyright © 2025 Makeup and Beauty Blog. Get in touch.